What Compute Indexes Can Learn from Other Rental Indexes
A compute index prices time-limited access to a non-storable asset, so its closest relatives are rental indexes, not oil or grain benchmarks. A barrel can be stored, so arbitrage ties spot to forward through the cost of carry. A GPU-hour, a ship-day or a month of an apartment is gone once the period ends, and what the renter gets depends on the asset’s condition and terms, not only the quantity. That raises three problems commodity benchmarks barely face: defining the asset, averaging across assets that are not alike, and checking that the access being priced exists.
Overnight money belongs in the set: a repo rents cash for a day against collateral, and the interest is the rent. Only shipping and overnight money pair a published rental benchmark with cleared derivatives, and that is where definitions are tightest.
| Market and benchmark | What the number is | Derivatives |
|---|---|---|
| Dry-bulk time charter: Baltic Capesize 5TC1 | $/day hire of a specified ship on defined routes, set by a broker panel checked by assessors2 | Cleared FFAs; a listed one-day-of-hire future3 |
| Overnight cash: SOFR4 | Volume-weighted median of overnight Treasury repo, published the next business day | SOFR futures; a record 13.7m contracts of open interest in August 20255 |
| Container time charter: New ConTex6 | Hire for eight ship classes at 6, 12 or 24 months, from an 11-broker panel | None found |
| Residential rent: BLS CPI rent7 and Zillow ZORI8 | BLS: rent on the same sampled units. ZORI: listed rents for new tenants | No rent futures found |
| Aircraft lease rentals9 | A valuation firm’s opinion of the prevailing lease rate | None found |
| Offshore rig day rates10 | Monthly average of contracts that start that month | None found |
| Power capacity: PJM auction11 | $/MW-day of accredited capacity, under an administrative cap | The auction is the price |
1. Fix a reference asset, then govern its succession
The Baltic prices one ship described to the tonne and the knot: a 182,000 dwt non-scrubber Capesize no more than 10 years old, with a four-speed fuel table1. Replacing that ship is a governed process that takes years. When the Panamax standard moved, derivatives followed only in January 2026, closing and reopening positions at the Baltic’s fixed $1,336 differential12,13. A vague reference costs money: a 2013 charter priced off the Capesize average without naming the ship ended in the High Court14. Money markets used the same device when LIBOR ended: the fallback spread was fixed on the day of the announcement, so every contract knew its offset in advance15.
Compute indexes will face the same roll when B200 supplants H100, and docket commenters have asked for a generation-roll rule16. A GPU bridge is harder than a ship bridge: one commenter puts the B200 premium over H100 at about 2.1× on one index and 3.0× on another, moving in opposite directions16. The reference should name a service a buyer recognizes — node, memory, partitioning, interconnect domain, power limit, region, term — and the succession policy should be published before contracts depend on it: trigger, notice, parallel publication, treatment of existing exposures, and a fallback if the bridge fails.
2. Keep the basket fixed, or compare a unit with itself
Shipping fixes the basket: five routes at published weights. Rent indexes price the same unit twice: BLS re-prices the same sampled units every six months7, and ZORI compares repeat rents for the same properties8. Both stop a change in the sample from reading as a change in price.
Compute indexes have no fixed basket. In an illustrative case, two classes priced at $4.00 and $2.00 see billed hours shift from 80/20 to 20/80: the blended average falls −33.3% with no class price changing17. A live case: a fixed H100 panel read $3.99 against a $3.45 weekly median on 2 October (−13.5%), because hyperscalers were 4 of 17 panel rates but 4 of 30 weekly rates16.
Rent also names a choice compute has not made. ZORI follows the flow of new leases; BLS follows the stock. An hourly on-demand index is a flow measure, and committed prices differ: in March 2026 a one-year H100 index read $2.35 an hour18, against on-demand readings of $2.64 and about $3.5019. A compute index should say which it measures.
3. Anchor on closed deals, and label the evidence
The Baltic does not use posted rates. Brokers who see closed fixtures give their judgment of the prevailing level; assessors validate every input against control prices kept out of the calculation; panelists may not trade derivatives on the routes they submit2. Money markets show what happens when a panel outlives its evidence: LIBOR rested on about $500 million of three-month funding a day, in roughly seven deals, against $200 trillion of contracts20. SOFR replaced the estimates with a median of observed trades4.
Compute has no broker layer. Its methodology should rank the evidence it accepts — executed transactions, then executable quotes, then expert assessments, then list prices — and say when a fallback applies. A provisioning test can stand in for the assessor: a success shows one account obtained a configuration at a stated price and time; a failure needs a reason code, because exhausted capacity, an account quota and a configuration error are different observations. Coverage belongs beside the index, and below a published threshold, non-publication beats a precise-looking number.
4. Define supply by a rule, and version the rule
In PJM’s capacity market a unit of supply is a rule. When PJM required demand response to be available in all hours, offered demand response moved −1.0% in installed terms but +32.0% in accredited terms11. A compute index faces the same problem with no registry of GPUs. It should publish the rule that turns hardware into deliverable supply — announced, installed and accepted for service, transferable — and report the quantity under both versions whenever the rule changes.
5. Let physical contracts adopt the index first
Freight derivatives grew because charterers already set period hire off the Baltic’s routes14. The venues came and went — BIFFEX closed in 2002 and its successor Baltex in 2017 — but the benchmark outlived both21. Housing futures stayed thin22, and no listed rent contract turned up. Compute is at the first stage: NYMEX’s H100 contract covers 730 GPU-hours23, about $2,168 at a $2.97 reading, and its review now runs to 8 January 202724. Writing the index into reserved-capacity contracts, with the benchmark version named, is the shipping route. The test is empirical: compare actual procurement or renewal prices with the reference and measure what the hedge leaves uncovered.
6. Govern the administrator, and watch administered prices
The Baltic’s independence rests on governance: board-approved methodology, an independent council on change and cessation, oversight of complaints and an annual external review2. A compute administrator should be barred from taking positions against its own index, with independent oversight of methodology changes.
PJM shows what a cap does to a published price. The 2028/29 auction cleared at $325.00/MW-day; PJM’s simulation without the cap gave $554.72, +70.7% higher, though it holds offers fixed and is not an observed uncapped price25,26. A flat posted GPU price is not a regulated cap, but it can hide scarcity the same way, so a compute index should publish a provisioning-success series beside the price.
What a compute index should do next
| Change | Precedent | Support in the CFTC docket |
|---|---|---|
| Name a reference grade and publish its performance profile | Baltic reference ships; New ConTex classes | 31% of letters on the unit favor a reference grade plus priced differentials |
| Fix the basket and its weights, with a reweighting trigger | Baltic 5TC route weights | 7 letters back fixed contributor floors or caps |
| Publish a succession rule before open interest exists | Baltic dual reporting; fixed Panamax differential | Several commenters ask for a roll rule |
| Validate evidence, keep control prices, bar administrator trading | Baltic assessors and panel rules | 15 letters back an administrator trading ban; 33 an independent audit |
| Define supply by a versioned rule | PJM accreditation | Proposed by Jump Trading, Fiftyrivers and others |
| Seed physical references before futures | Baltic-linked charter hire | 22 letters want physical delivery alongside cash |
Counts are from CCIR’s summary of the public comments27. The same standard applies to Babbage’s own B200 series, which is built from posted list prices and does not yet apply the verification proposed in 014. The objective is to preserve the economic meaning of the reference as the market changes — and when that meaning must change, to tell users how, why and what happens to the contracts that depend on it.
References
- Baltic Exchange, Dry services and vessel definitions. balticexchange.com
- Baltic Exchange, Benchmark production process (BEISL white paper). balticexchange.com
- ICE, Capesize Timecharter future specification. ice.com
- Federal Reserve Bank of New York, SOFR methodology. newyorkfed.org
- CME Group, record SOFR futures open interest, 14 August 2025. cmegroup.com
- VHBS, New ConTex revision, 2026. ics.org.uk
- US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Measuring changes in shelter prices, 2022. bls.gov
- Adams, Loewenstein, Montag and Verbrugge, online appendix on rent indexes. aeaweb.org
- ch-aviation, What are lease rentals. ch-aviation.com
- Kaiser and Snyder, Analyzing rig day rates, Offshore, 2012. offshore-mag.com
- PJM, 2027/2028 Base Residual Auction report, December 2025. pjm.com
- Dry Bulk, Baltic Exchange on the Panamax FFA transfer and 182k Capesize, January 2026. drybulkmagazine.com
- EEX, P4TC open interest transfer notice, January 2026. eex.com
- Regal Seas v Oldendorff (The New Hydra), High Court, 2021. nationalarchives.gov.uk
- ISDA, LIBOR cessation and the impact on fallbacks, 5 March 2021. isda.org
- CFTC, public comments on the listing of compute derivatives, docket CFTC-2026-1850. regulations.gov
- Babbage Research 014, Defining the Compute Behind the Price. babbageindex.com
- SemiAnalysis, H100 one-year rental price index, April 2026. semianalysis.com
- TechFlow via KuCoin, GPU price indices diverge, April 2026. kucoin.com
- ARRC, Factsheet 1: why LIBOR is being replaced, 2020. newyorkfed.org
- FreightWaves, Will the end of Baltex allow room for another freight futures exchange, 2017. freightwaves.com
- Tokic and Tokic, Home Price Indices Futures, 2008. cre.org
- NYMEX Submission 26-370, Silicon Data H100 and B200 GPU rental futures, August 2026. cftc.gov
- CME Group, letter to the CFTC extending the review of Submission 26-370 to 8 January 2027, 4 November 2026. cftc.gov
- PJM, 2028/2029 Base Residual Auction report, appendix tables 1–2 and footnote 4, July 2026. pjm.com
- POWER, PJM’s 2028/2029 capacity auction, July 2026. powermag.com
- CCIR, Compute derivatives: a summary of public comments, October 2026. ccir.io
Provenance note, per house style. Illustrative: the two-class mix shift (from 014). Computed on this page: the −33.3% mix-shift change, the −13.5% panel gap, the −1.0% and +32.0% demand-response changes, the +70.7% no-cap premium and the contract value. Quoted: all other figures, from the references; docket figures are commenters’ own claims.